An Analysis of Interactions among Influential Factors Contributing to Social Participation in the Historic Bazaar of Tabriz through the Lens of Latour Actor-Network Theory: A Grounded Theory

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Department of Architecture, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Tabriz, Iran.

Abstract

Problem statement: The actor-network theory offers a new approach to solving a variety of problems such as social participation. This new approach sets a good platform to track the trajectory of human (people and the element of power) and inhuman (space) actors. In this model, to create social participation, it is necessary to establish a kind of power relations in which space also acts alongside the people and the institution of power.
Research objective: The current study aims to analyze the process of interactions among the three elements of people, the institution of power and space, and explains its effect on social participation in the historic bazaar of Tabriz.
Research Method: This research draws upon actor-network theory to examine human and nonhuman actors in the network using the qualitative method. The present study is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-analytical in terms of nature. To this end, the grounded theory method was used and semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted (Data-driven methods). The data were gathered through in-depth interviews with 45 marketeers in the grand bazaar of Tabriz, experts, and authorities (city managers) as knowledgeable in this field.
Conclusion: Many problems associated with urban systems, including the structure of historic markets in Iran, arise from non-democratic actors such as lack of participation, violation of civil rights, lack of awareness, inflexibility in government decisions, and the decline in pluralism. The results of the research based on the evidence and interviews indicate that the improvement of the spatial component of Tabriz historic bazaar depends on raising the awareness of marketeers and creating a positive role for them in various decisions. This process needs to create equal opportunities to raise the awareness of the citizens and respect the position of the people, not as a problem but as a solution. However, in parallel with this, strengthening both economic structures and the sense of belonging play a double role.

Keywords


Abbott, J. (2013). Sharing the city: community participation in urban management. London: Routledge.
Aghajani Refah, R., Norouzborazjani, V. & Nejad Ebrahimi, A. (2021). Analysis of social and physical factors underlies the participation of bazaars in the continuation of the life of the historical market of Tabriz. Journal of New Attitudes in Human Geography, 13(2), 788-806.
Arnstein, Sh. R. (1996). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35 (4), 216-224.
Baghestani Barzaki, H. (2008). The effect of citizens' awareness of citizenship rights on the development of active citizenship and accountability and transparency of Tehran Municipality (Unpublished Master Thesis in Urban Management). Department of Urban Management, University of Tehran, Iran.
Beheshti Asl, A., Ebrahimi, M. & Azizi, A. (2019). Analysis of the concept of memorization in the continuation of spatial attachment in the historical market of Tabriz. Journal of Urban Design Studies and Urban Research, 2(3), 40-56.
Behzadfar, M. & Tahmasebi, A. (2013). Recognition and assessment of influential elements on social interaction (strengthening and improving citizen communication in urban open spaces, model city of Sanandaj). Bagh-e Nazar, 10(25), 17-28.
Banitalebi Dehkordi, B., Rahnamay Roodpashti, F., Nikomaram, H. & Talebnia, Gh. (2015). Explaining Actor Network Theory in Accounting from the perspective of knowledge. Journal of Management Accounting and Auditing Knowledge, 4(16), 119-130.
Botterill, L. C. & Fisher, M. (2002). Magical thinking: The rise of the community participation model. Paper presented at the Jubilee conference of the Australasian Political Studies Association, Australian National University, Canberra.
Cicognani, E., Pirini, C., Keyes, C., Joshanloo, M., Rostami, R. & Nosratabadi, M. (2008). Social Participation, Sense of Community and Social Well Being: A Study on American, Italian and Iranian University Students. Social Indicators Research, 89(1), 97–112.
Creswell, J. W. (2009). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches. Los Angeles: Sage.
Eslami, Gh. & Kamelnia, H. (2013). Community Architecture: From Theory to Practice. Tehran: University of Tehran.
Esmaili Sangari, H. & Omrani, B. (2014), "World Heritage Site of Tabriz Historical Bazaar Complex (Measures and Challenges). Journal of Restoration and Cultural Heritage, 2(4), 91-75.
Fakouhi, N. (2009). Sheklgiri-ye hoviat va olgou-ha-ye mahali, melli va jahani, nemone moredi: Lorestan [Formation of local, national and global identities and patterns, case study: Lorestan]. Iranian Journal of Sociology, 4(4), 127-161.
Fani, Z. (2013). Space, Scale and Globalization with Analysis of Actor-Network Theory (ANT), Quarterly. Journal of Strategic Studies of Globalization, 4(12), 93-106.
Foroutan, M., Araqchian, M. & Sanatgar Kakhki, M. (2011). The Role of Traditional Markets in the Spatial Structure of Islamic and Iranian Cities (Unpublished Architecture Master Thesis). Islamic Azad University of Hamadan, hamedan, Iran.
Ghazi Tabatabai, M. & Vaddahir, A. (2007). Jame'e shenasi elm-e fanavari, taamoli bar tahavolat-e akhir-e Jame'e shenasi-ye elm [Sociology of Science Technology, a Reflection on Recent Developments in the Sociology of Science]. Journal of Social Science Letter, 31(1) 125-142.
Granier, B. & Kudo, H. (2016). How are citizens involved in smart cities? Analysing citizen participation in Japanese “Smart Communities”. Information Polity, 21(1), 61-76.
Habibi, M. & Rezvani, S. (2006). Shahrsazi-ye mosharekati, tamayoz-e mafhomi va arzyabi-ye tajrobiat-e Irani [Participatory Urban Planning, conceptual differentiation, and evaluation of Iranian experiences]. Soffeh, 15(43), 50-70.
Hagh Parast, F. & Esmaeili Sangari, H. (2018). Manage the World Heritage Sites in Tabriz, relying on popular participation. Urban Management, 17(50), 145-162.
Hagh Parast, F. & Esmaeili Sangari, H. (2019). The process of formation and development the Tabriz historical bazaar in the social participation context After the earthquake of 1194 AH. Quarterly of Geography (Regional Planing), 9(4), 515-533.
Hatami Golzari, E., Mirza Kouchak khoshnevis, A., Bayazidi, Q. & Habibi, F. (2019). Analysis of influential components in architectural stability of historical Bazars of Iran: the case of Tabriz historical Bazar. Journal of Sustainable Architecture and Urban Design, 7(1), 129-143.
Helliwell, J. F., Huang, H. & Wang, S. (2014). Social capital and well-being in times of crisis. Journal of Happiness Studies, 15(1), 145-162.
Javedani, A. & Parvin, M. (2015). Space-people Participation or Connection of Political Affairs to Urban Space (Case Study: Bab-al-vazir district and Tahrir Square, Cairo, 2012).. Bagh e Nazar, 12(34), 109–124.
Latour, B. (2005): Reassembling the Social, an Introduction for Actor-Network Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press Inc,
Juarez, J. A. & Brown, K. D. (2008). Extracting or empowering? A critique of participatory methods for marginalized populations. Landscape Journal, 27(2), 190-204.
Latifi, Gh. & Ahmadi, H. (2010). Shahrvandi va shahrsazi-ye mosharekati [Citizenship and Participatory Urban Planning]. Ketab-e Mah-e Olom-e Ejtema'e, 36, 55-63.
Lefebvre, H. (2003). The Urban Revolution (R. Bononno, Trans.). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Lotfi, B. (2010). Spatial agency, the role of Tehran’s freedom square in protests of 1979 and 2009. Budapest: Central European University.
Marsousi, N. (2011). The Study of Economic Function of Tabriz Bazaarand its Surrounding Areas. Human Geography Research Quarterly, 43(75), 133-152.
Mehri, F. & Davoudpour, Z. (2019). Application of Space Syntax Theory in Reduction of the Socio- spatial Segregation of Urban Neighborhoods. Human Geografy Research Quarterly, 51(2), 357-371.
Mohammadi Kalan, A. & Oliveira, E. (2015). The sustainable architecture of bazaars and its relation with social, cultural and economic components (Case study: the historic Bazaar of Tabriz). International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development, 5(4), 5-12.
Mozayeni, M. (1999). Sakhtar-e modiriat-e shahri dar Iran [Urban management structure in Iran]. Tehran: Markaz-e Motale'at va barnamerizi-ye Shahri.
Niazi, M. (2005). Explaining the Status of Social Cooperation of the Citizens of Kashan. Journal of Studies on Kashan, 1(2), 127-147.
Norouzborazjani, V. (2015), Qualitative Research Methodology. Tehran: Yadavaran International Research and Publishing Company.
Piran, P. (1995). Barname-ye jame' agahsazi be soye paydari va shahrnadmadari [Comprehensive Awareness Program towards Sustainability and Citizenship]. Tehran: Daftar-e Pajohesh-ha-ye Farhangi.
Pourezzat, A., Gholipr, A. & Baghestani, H. (2010). The Relationship between Citizens' Awareness of the Citizenship Rights and Organization's Accountability and Transparency. Scientific Quarterly. Social Welfare Quarterly, 10(38), 38 -45.
Rabbani, M. & Taheri, A. (2009). A Sociological Explication of Purity Status among the Inhabitants of the New City of Baharestan, Isfahan. Journal of Social Sciences, 2(5), 91-129.
Radadi, M. (2008). Components of social capital in Islam. Tehran: Imam Sadegh University Press.
Rafieian, M. & Alvandipour, N. (2015). Right to the city; In search of a conceptual model. Iranian Journal of Sociology, 16(2), 25-47.
Rostami, K. (2003). the Role of Public Participation in Rural Development with Emphasis on Traditional and New Participation (Case Study: Qlard Ward, Lordegan County) (Unpublished M.Sc. Thesis in Geography and Urban Planning). Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Rowe, M. & Ponce, A. N. (2020). How Shall We Promote Citizenship and Social Participation? I In: H.H. Goldman, R.G. Frank, J.P. Morrissey (Eds.). Handbook of U.S. Mental Health Policy. London, UK: Palgrave MacMillan; 2019. pp. 573–599.
Saeedi, M.R. (2003). An Introduction to Public Participation and Non-Governmental Organizations. Tehran: Samat Publications.
Saedvandi, M. & Mahvash, M. (2016). Pathology of Indexing of Islamic concepts in Islamic Architecture. Journal of Studies of Iranian-Islamic City, 21(3), 47-56.
Sharbatian, M. & Aminian, A. (2013). Measuring the Social Capital among the Students of Payamnoor University in Southern Khorasan and its Effective Factors. Sociological Studies of Youth Journal, 3(9), 93-114.
Sharafi, M. & Barakpur, N. (2010). Typology of Public Participation Techniques in Urban Planning based on Different Levels of Participation. Journal of Architecture and Urban Planning, 2(4), 77-100.
Sharifzadeh, M., Zamani, Gh., Karami, E., Iman, M. & Khalili, D. (2012). The approach of the network theory of actors and its application in the study of agricultural climatic information system. Journal of Science and Technology Research, 28(2), 433-454.
Sharifzadeh, R. (2015). Negotiation with Objects, Bruno Latour and Theory of Network Operator. Tehran: Ney.
Siami, Gh., Akhtari Takaleh, A. & Kahnizadeh, M. (2016). Evaluation of economic vivaciousness criteria in historic bazaars of Iran: developing a recreation point of view: the case of Qazvin historic bazaar. Amayesh-e Mohit, 9(34), 1-26.
Taghvaei, M, Babanasab, R. & Mousavi, Ch. (2009). Tahlili bar sanjesh-e avamel-e moaser bar mosharekat-e shahrvandan dar modiriat-e shahri motale'-ye moredi: mantaghe-ye 4 shahr-e Tabriz [An Analysis of Measuring Factors Affecting Citizens' Participation in Urban Management Case Study: Region 4 of Tabriz]. Urban Regional Studies and Research, 1(2), 19- 26.
Toutakhane, A. M. (2018). Influencing factors on performance of social behavior settings at parks and green spaces of Tabriz. Journal of Urban and Regional Analysis, 10(2), 199-215.
Tomé, V., Lopes, P., Reis, B. & Dias, C. P. (2019). Active citizenship and participation through the media: a community project focused on pre-school and primary school children. Comunicação e Sociedade, 36, 101–120.
Wu, F. (2012). Neighborhood Attachment, Social Participation, and Willingness to Stay in China’s Low-Income Communities. Urban Affairs Review, 48(4), 547–570.
Xiao, L., Zhang, G., Zhu, Y. & Lin, T. (2017). Promoting public participation in household waste management: A survey based method and case study in Xiamen city, China. Journal of Cleaner production, 144, 313-322.
Yazdanian, A. & Keshtkar, V. (2016). The impact of the public sphere on the participation of citizens in urban affairs, with an emphasis on urban regeneration. Haft Shahr, 4(53 & 54), 157-173.