The Investigation of the Challenge of “Islamic Architecture” and “Muslim Architecture”

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Lecturer, School of Architecture, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran

2 Professor, Faculty of Architecture, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Iran.

3 Professor, Faculty of Theology, University of Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Abstract
Problem statement: Numerous studies have been conducted on the subject of Islamic architecture, but this article aims to challenge the concepts of “Islamic architecture” and “Muslim architecture” and distinguish between the two. The topic that has not been addressed so far is the definition of these two religious terms within the realm of religion.
In this regard, the following questions are raised:- What is Islamic architecture?- What is Muslim architecture?- What is the difference between Islamic architecture and Muslim architecture?- Is Islamic architecture obtainable in modern times?
Research objective: Understanding the reality of Islamic architecture and Muslims architecture, as well as distinguishing between these two, are the research objectives that are essential for research in this redard.
Research method: This article examines the relationships between architecture as a science and Islam in terms of their types of connection. In this context, the opinions of scholars regarding the nature of Islamic architecture were studied using available library documents, and these definitions were classified into three categories: physical, semantic, and behavioral. Since religion determines the requirements and limits of Muslim behavior and does not consider physical constraints for architecture, understanding the true nature of Islamic architecture is essential. To understand this truth, studies were conducted using inductive reasoning methods, and Shia sources were scrutinized to define a new concept of Islamic architecture as the result of implementing the correct form and adhering to religious commands without any deficiencies or excesses.
Conclusion: According to this definition, examples of buildings designed for Muslims are introduced in this article under the title of “Muslim architecture”. Muslim architecture is derived from incomplete interpretations, attempts, and efforts of Muslims to follow religious instructions, which are accompanied by personal tastes and understanding, prescribed laws, and ignorance, resulting in a gap compared to Islamic architecture. By studying pathological features and searching for the causes of this gap, Muslim architecture can be brought closer to Islamic architecture. To clarify this gap and its causes, the distinction between the two concepts of Islamic architecture and Muslim architecture is discussed.

Keywords

References

Abbasi Sarmadi, M. & Mashayekh, M. (2016). Explanation of The Role of Requirements of Time and Space in The Process of Individual Inference (A Study of The Viewpoints of Imamiya Jurisprudents With Special Emphasis on Imam Khomeini’s Viewpoints). PAZHUHESHNAMEH MATIN, 18(72 ), 97-122. 
Aleghafour, S. M. (2005). Ejtehad va Taghlid dar Andishe ye Aleman e Shi’e [Ijtihad and Taqlid in the Thoughts of Shia scholars]. Political Science, 8(31), 99-120.
Aliabadi, M. (2015).  How is the Return of “Identity” to the Islamic Art and Architecture? CIAUJ, 1 (1), 15-38.
Al-Kulayni, M. (2022). Al-Kafi(6). Retrieved from https://rizy.ir/IgpXD.
Ardalan, N. & Bakhtiar, L. (2011). The Sense of Unity: The Sufi Tradition in Persian Architecture. (V. Jalili, Trans.). Tehran: Elm-e Memar Publication (Original Work Published 1973).
Attoe, W. (2009). Architecture and Critical Imagination. (A. Andjomshoaa Trans.). Tehran: Matn Publication, 2nd Edition (Original Work Published 1978).
Azizian Qaravi, M., & Azizian Qaravi, Z. (2020). A Comparative Analysis of Islamic Housing Indicators on Traditional Houses of Qom City, Based on Muslim Architects’ Opinions. JOURNAL OF RESEARCHES IN ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURE, 7(4 (25) ), 115-138.
Blair, Sh. & Bloom, J. A. (2002). The Art Architecture of Islam (2) (1250-1800). (Y. Azhand, Trans.). Tehran: SAMT Publication. (Original Work Published 1994).
Bolkhari, H. (2015). Ghadr Nazarie ye Honar va Zibaee dar Tamadon e Eslami [Qadr: The theory of Art and Beauty in Islamic Civilization]. Tehran: Soore Mehr Publication.
Bolkhari, H. (2009). Mabani e Erfani e Honar va Memari e Eslami [The Mystical Foundations of Islamic Art and Architecture]. Tehran: Soore Mehr Publication.
Burckhardt, T. (1986). Art of Islam; Language and Meaning. (M. Rajabnia, Trans.). Soroush Publication. (Original Work Published 1976).
Ettinghausen, R. & Grabar, O. (2015). The Art and Architecture of Islam 650 -1250. (Y. Azhand, Trans.). Tehran: SAMT Publication. (Original Work Published 1987).
Fallah Yakhdani, M. J. & Alipoor Anjaei, M. H. (2018). Take a Look at the Concept and Jurisprudential Ruling of Similarity to the Infidels. Researches in Jurisprudential , 5(9), 117-146.
Ghorbani, R. (2014). Memari va Shahrsazi e Matlub e Eslami(Matlibiat e Eslam Darbareye Maskan [Desirable Islamic Architecture and Urban Planning (Islamic Perspective on Housing)]. Tehran: Shabake ye Andisheh Publication.
Grabar, O., Beest Holle, V., Gierlichs, J., Hattstein, M., Mazot, S., Ettinghouse, R., Jonnelli, J., Blair, S., Hagedorn, A., Steele, J., Kubisch, N., Barrucand, M., Von Gladiss, A., Meineck_ Berg, V. J., Du Rey, K., Foster, S., Delius, P., Voughan, P., Bloom, J., Chmelnizkij, S. & Enderlrin, V. (2012). Islam: Art and Architecture (A. Gheytasi, Trans.). Tehran: Soore Mehr Publication. (Original Work Published 2000).
Groat, L. & Wang, D. (2011). Architectural Research Methods. (A. Eynifar Trans.). Tehran: University of Tehran Publication, 7th Edition. (Original Work Published 2002).
Grube, E. (2000). Architecture of the Islamic World: Its History and Social Meaning. (Y. Azhand, Trans.). Tehran: Mola Publication. (Original Work Published 1978).
Grupico, T. (2011). The Dome in Christian and Islamic Sacred Architecture. Retrieved Jan5, 2022, from https://rizy.ir/mFm0j
Hillenbrand, R. (2007). Islamic Architecture: Form, Function, and Meaning. (I. Etesam Trans.). Tehran: Pardazesh Publication. (Original Work Published 1994).
Hoag, J. D. & Martin, H. (2009). Sabkshenasi e Honar e Memari dar Sarzaminhaye Eslami [Stylistic Analysis of Art and Architecture in Islamic lands]. (P. Varjavand Trans.). Tehran: ELMI-FARHANGI Publishing Company.
Imani, N. (2004). Architecture and Islam.(Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis in Architecture). University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
Islami, S. GH. (2013). Lessons on Architectural Theory Let us Make our Own Glasses. Tehran: Elm-e Memar Publication.
Itewi, M. (2007). Towards a Modern Theory of Islamic Architecture. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, (2), 153-156.
Khamenei, A. (2011). Ensan e 250 Sale [A 250 Years Old Person]. Tehran: SAHBA Publication.
Mahmoud, M. F. & Elbelkasy, M. I. (2016). Islamic Architecture: Between Moulding and Flexibility, This Paper is Part of the Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Islamic Heritage Architecture and Art. WIT Transactions on The Built Environment, (159), Retrieved Sep21, 2022, from https://www.witpress.com/Secure/elibrary/papers/IHA16/IHA16005FU1.pdf
Majlesi, M. B. (1984). Biḥar al-Anwar al-Jamiʿah li-Durar Akhbar al-Aʾimmah al-Aṭhār (Vol 23,52,72) [Seas of Lights: The Collection for Pearls of Traditions of the Pure Imams]. Beirut: Muʾassasat al-Wafā.
Mardani, M. (2019). Modernizing the Holy Prophet’s Deeds: The Methods and Instances. Conduct Studies of Ahl-ol-Bayt, 5(9), 11-28.
Mas’oudy, A. (2005). Az Mafhum ta Maghsood (Talash haye Allame Mohammad Taqi Majlesi dar Fahm e Maqsud e Hadith) [From Concept to Intention (the Efforts of Allameh Mohammad Taghi Majlesi to Understand the Intention of Hadith)]. Ulum-i Hadith, (1-2), 26-51.
Mesbah-Yazdi, M. T. (n.d. a). Rabete ye Elm va Din [The Relationship Between Science and Religion]. Retrieved Jan 23, 2019 from http://mesbahyazdi.ir/node/5244.
Mesbah-Yazdi, M. T. (n.d. b). Porsesh va Pasokh(Ahlebeyt Ensane Kamel va Kameltarin Ensanha yand) [Questions and Answers (the Ahlul Bayt are the perfect and Most Complete Human Beings)]. Retrieved Jan 23, 2019 from http://mesbahyazdi.ir/node/2858.
Moazzemi, M. (2008). Jaygah e Dars e Ashnaee ba Memari e Eslami dar Dore ye Amuzeshi e Memari ba Negahi bar Tajarob e Sayer e Keshvar ha dar Amoozesh e Tarikh e Memari [The Position of Familiarity with Islamic Architecture in the Architectural Education Curriculum with a Look at the Experiences of Other Countries in Teaching the History of Architecture.]. The Third Conference on Architecture Education. Conducted by Fine Arts: University of Tehran.
Mortada, H. (2008). Traditional Islamic Principles of Built Environmen (A. Meshkini, Trans.). Tehran: UARC Publication. (Original Work Published 2003).
 Motahhari, M. (1993). An Introduction to the Islamic World View, Monotheistic Conception of the World. Tehran: Sadra Publication. Retrieved Sep 21, 2022 from https://www.aviny.com/library/motahari/Books/39/index.htm.
Motahhari, M. (1994). Islam and the Requirements of the Time (1). Tehran: Sadra Publication. Retrieved Sep 21, 2022 from https://www.aviny.com/library/motahari/Books/4/index.htm.
Motahhari, M. (2011). The End of Prophecy. Tehran: Sadra Publication.
Naghizadeh, M. (1999). Manabe va Ravesh e Shenakht e Mabani e Nazari e Memari e Ghodsi va Shahr e Eslami [Sources and Methods for Understanding the Theoretical Foundations of Sacred Architecture and Islamic Cities]. Honor, (40), 99-116.
Naghizadeh, M. (2003). Jostari dar Chisty e Eslamiyyat e Honar va Memari Iran [A Discussion on the Essence of Islamic Art and Architecture in Iran]. The Modares Semiannual Art, (3), 111-118.
Narighomi, M. (2013). Theory of Islamic Architecture vs. Islamic Theory of Architecture: A Critical Appraisal of the Contemporary Theoretical and Practical Approaches from the Islamic Perspective. The Second National Conference Islamic Architecture & Urbanism. Conducted by Tabriz Islamic Art University: Tabriz.
Narighomi, M. (2017). Raveshshenasi ye Manabe e Pajuhesh dar Mored e Rabete ye Memari e Maskuni va Eslam [Methodology of Research sources on the relationship Between Residential Architecture and Islam]. MSSH, (89), 29-56.
Nasr, S. H. (2010). Islamic Art Spirituality (R. Ghasemian, Trans.). Tehran: Hekmat Publication (Original Work Published 1990).
Noghrekar, A. (2008). Daramadi bar Hovyat e Eslami dar Memari va Shahrsazi [An Introduction to Islamic Identity in Architecture and Urban Planning]. Tehran: Payamsima Publication.
Noghrekar, A. & Raeesi, M. M. (2012). REALIZATION OF ISLAMIC IDENTITY IN ARCHITECTURAL WORKS. JOURNAL OF STUDIES ON IRANIAN ISLAMIC CITY, 2(7), 5-12.
Noghrekar, A. (2013a). House of Kaaba; Fundamental Cell of Designing Fine Places of Worship Exploring Strategic Principles and Practical Solutions of Fine Mosque Design. Journal of Research in Islamic Architecture, 1(1), 25-41.
Noghrekar, S. (2013b). Memari e “Memari” bar Mabna ye Andishe ye Eslami [Architecture of “Architecture” based on Islamic Thought]. The Second National Conference Islamic Architecture & Urbanism. Conducted by Tabriz Islamic Art University: Tabriz.
Norberg-Shulz, K. (2007). Meaning in Western Architecture. (M. Qayyoomi Bidhendi Trans.). Tehran: Iranian Academy of Arts Publication. (Original Work Published 1975).
Nouri, E. & Dizani, E. (2021). Finding the Architectural Pattern of Chinese Mosques (Case Study: The Great Mosque of Xian). MANZAR, 13(56), 54-61.
Omer, S. (2011). ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURE AND THE PROSPECT OF ITS REVIVAL TODAY, Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization, (1), 103-121.
Parsania, H. (2019). The Quiddity of Religious Science with Emphasis on the Viewpoint of Professor Javadi Amoli. Isra Hikmat, 9(1), 63-92.
Pirnia, M. K. (2004). Sabkshenasi-e Memari-e Irani [Stylistic Analysis of Iranian Architecture]. Tehran: Memar Publication.
Price, C. (1985). The Story of Moslem Art. (M. Rajabnia,Trans.). ELMI-FARHANGI Publishing Company. (Original Work Published 1964).
Qarashi Banabi, A. A. (1385). Ghamoos e Qoran(5) [Dictionary of the Quran]. Tehran: Darol Kotob el Eslamiye Publication.
Raeesi,  M. M. (2019). Analyzing the Superiority of Introversive Patterns in the Architectural Designing of Residential Buildings Based on Quranic Literature. ARMANSHAHR, 12(27), 77-85.
Saoud, R. (2002.). Introduction to Islamic Architecture. Retrieved Jan5, 2022, from https://muslimheritage.com/introduction-to-islamic-architecture/
Sartipi Pour, M. (2000). Ahkam e Feghgi va Memari e Masjed [Jurisprudence and Architecture of Mosques]. Housing And Rural Environment, (91&92), 6-19.
Serageldin, I. (n.d.). Faith and the Environment: An Inquiry into Islamic Principles and the Built Environment of Muslims. Retrieved Jan5, 2022, from https://rizy.ir/L8tUuZu
Stimson, A. (2012). Domes, Arches, and Minarets: Islamic Architecture in America. Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, 38-39 Retrieved Jan5, 2022, from https://rizy.ir/6hNKpD
Tabatabai,, M. H. (1995). Tarjomeh ye Tafsir e Almizan(8) [Translation of Tafsir al-Mizan]. Qom: Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom.
Tabatabai,, M. H. (2008). The Teaching of Islam. Qom: Bustan Ketab Publication.
Zolfagharzadeh, H. (2014). An Analysis of Attitudes towards Islamic Architecture . JRIA, 2 (2), 29-45.
The Monthly Scientific Journal of Bagh-e Nazar
Volume 20, Issue 127
January 2023
Pages 49-60

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics