Essence of Hermeneutic Circle of Understanding in Aesthetics of Photograph Interpretation

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

null

Abstract

In classical hermeneutics, the process of understanding is a mental operation realized the live human experience by it. Understanding opens our world and to us. According to Heidegger, understanding is the power to understand one’s own possibilities for existence and in the context of the global environment which the man lives in. The achievement way of the understanding, understanding layers and the issue of circularity of understanding are the concerns of the hermeneutic and ontological theologians. In this regard, Roland Barthes, in his latest book, "Camera Lucida", in an understanding achieved from the photo as a text, considers the entities of the photograph context in a rotating circle of the audience and the life context and the dialectical relationship between the particular audience of the photo, the context of the photograph and the tradition in which the audience and the photo have raised. The circularity of understanding is one of the important issues discussed in the hermeneutics of Schleiermacher that today it is known as hermeneutical circle.  In the history of the philosophy, Schleiermacher has remembered as the father of the modern hermeneutics. He has delivered the circularity of understanding to describe the understanding the text. While the later, Martin Heidegger and his student, Hans-Georg Gadamer, in his hermeneutical theory, did not dedicate this issue to the understanding and they developed and expanded this circle to the fundamental principle of human understanding on the nature and his state. Hermeneutics circle, totally, describes this issue that how the component and the whole, in the process of understanding and interpretation, are related to each other in form of a circle: understanding the components is necessary for understanding the whole, while understanding the components, there should be understood the whole. Our understanding of photos depends on the current situation of the interpretation and the interpreter and also the interpretation of photos is related to the world that the photo describes it. The appearance of such understanding circle can be observed so well in actions and reactions of the photography and in the conditions of the truthful sight. This paper, based on the text "Camera Lucida", has investigated the nature of hermeneutic circle of understanding on the interpretation of photographic works and has attempted to explore the representations of the understanding circle in the context of the photo.

Keywords


Barthes, R. (2005). Otaagh-e Roshan: Andishe-haaei Darbaare-ye Akkassee [Camera Lucida: Reflection on Photography]. Translated from English by: Motaref, N. Tehran: Cheshmeh Publications.
Barthes, R. (2006). Roland Bart Be ravaayat-e Roland Bart [Roland Barthes Per Roland Barthes]. Translated from English by Yazdanjou, P. Tehran: Markaz Publications.
Barret, T. (2006). Naghd-e Aks [Criticizing Photograhs: An introduction to Understanding Images]. Translated from English by Abbasi, E. and Mir Abbasi, K. Tehran: Markaz Publications.
Batchen, G. (2009). Photography Degree Zero, Reflections on Roland Barthes’s Camera Lucida. London: The MIT Press.
Couzens hoy, D. (2006). Halghe-ye Enteghaadi [Critical circle]. Translated from English by Farhadpour, M. Tehran: Publication of intellectuals and women’s studies.
Grondis, J. (1994). Introduction to philosophical hermeneutics. London: Yale University press.
Flusser, V. (2008). Dar Baab-e- Falsafe-ye Akkassee [Towaard a philosophy of photography]. Translated from English by Bayrami, P. Tehran: Herfeh Honarmand Publications. (Original work published in 2000)
Johnson, P. A. (2009). Raah-e Maartin Haideger [Martin Heidegger’s way]. Translated from English by Kamali, M. Tehran: Mehr Niusha Publications. (Original work published in 2004)
Morris, E. (2015). Eteghaad Be Shaahed [Believing Is Seeng (Observations On the Mysteries Of Photography)]. Translated from English by Nabavi, R. Tehran: Patogh Publications.
Mardiha, N. (2013). Haghighat Ya Lezzat [Truth or pleasure]. Andishe Pouya, (7): 57.
Moghimnejad, M. (2014). Akkassee va nazarieh [Photography and theory]. Tehran: Soure Mehr Publication.
Noss. J. B. (1991). Taarikh-e Jaame-e Adyaan [Man’s Religions]. Translated from English by Hekmat, A. Tehran: Elmi Farhangi Publications. (Original work published in 1956)
Palmer, R. (2008). Elm-e Hermrnotic [Hermeneutics]. Translated from English by Hanaee Kashani, M. S. Tehran: Hermes Publications.
Ahmadi, B. (2008). Haghighat va zibaaei [Truth and Beauty]. Tehran: Markaz Publications.
Vaezi, A. (2007). Daramdi Bar Hermenotic [Introduction to hermeneutics]. Tehran: Organization of Islamic Thought and Culture Research Publications.
Shamisa, S. (2007). Naghd-e- Adabi. Tehran: Mitra.
Sherratt, Y. (2008). Falsafe-e Oloum-e Ejtemaaei Gharrei [Continental philosophy of the social sciences]. Translated from English by Galilee, H. Tehran: Ney Publications.
Wells, L. (2011). Akkassee: Daramadi Enteghaadi [Photography: a critical Introduction]. Translated from English by Khataeelar, S., Ghodsi, V. & Mohajer, M. Tehran: Minouye Kherad Publications. (Original work published in 2004)
Wells, L. (2012). Nazarie-ye Akkassee [The Photography Reader]. Translated from English by Akhgar, M. Tehran: Samt Publications. (Original work published in 2003)